Categories

Stop Copying Me

Mar 4
prada-2011-02

Remember when I discussed my disgust over counterfeit bags?  If not, you can catch up here.  I recently found this article on The High Low and I thought it would be a great  connection to start another conversation on the topic of artistic license.

We’ve all heard about the YSL v. Louboutin case.  It’s a known fact that Zara mimics the runways and has it in stores 3 weeks later.  We also know about how Forever 21 likes to have eerily similar pieces to other famous designers. Case in point below: Anna Sui vs. Forever 21 knockoff.

Where do we draw the line? While I agree that the majority of the population cannot afford designer fashion, does that give fast fashion retailers the right to infringe on a designer’s vision? It’s a very thin line that calls for the professionals, aka the law.  I am very interested in the difference between an inspiration, say a color scheme or silhouette, versus blatant copying.

I think you all know my feelings on this subject.  My viewpoint: get your own ideas.  I see it no different than plagiarism.  I understand the motives. I get it.  Companies want to make money.  The trickle down effect has been in place for centuries and will probably never go away.  However, using a print that is barely indistinguishable (such as above) should be cause for major reparations.  There are other ways to go about portraying a trend and capturing “the look” of the season.  C’est la vie!  Until major legal changes are made, I believe this will continue to happen.

What are your feelings on the matter?

 

  • http://www.atlanticstylediaries.com Chelsea

    It’s true, in some ways it’s not a lot better than the fake designer bags- however, at least brands like Zara and Forever 21 are not putting fake brand logos on their products, claiming them to be something they are not.
    When you get into logo stealing that is where you infringe on copyright laws. However, we know that in the art/design world it’s hard to stake claim to a pattern. For example, Zara may be clearly copying that Prada sweater, but, at the same time, blue and black horizontal stripes isn’t an original idea by Prada. It’s been done before. Also, the two sweaters may looks similar, but the quality in the make, materials, stitching is going to shine through and set the 2 apart.
    I once watched a really interesting TED video explaining copyright laws and the lack-thereof in the fashion industry- it’s an interesting debacle. http://www.ted.com/talks/view/lang/en//id/866.

    • Lindsay

      That’s a great way to think about it. It’s such a tough call to make and I can definitely hop on both fences. I think that’s why the fashion industry is in the state it’s in. I’ll definitely have to watch that video. Thanks for the heads up and view from the other side!

  • http://www.averysweetblog.com/ Kim

    The Anna Sui vs. F21 is going wayyy too far. That definitely screams infringement. I wasn’t aware of this. You’ve given me something to think about Lindsay.

  • http://blondehairbluejeans.blogspot.com/ Blonde Hair, Blue Jeans

    the 2nd one is an obvious copy

    • Lindsay

      I know, right?!